In June 2025, Bob Vila and Diana Barrett sold their estate at 690 Island Drive for $33 million. Vila is the host of "This Old House" and a former chairman of the Palm Beach Architectural Commission. The house dated to 1949. The couple had remodeled and expanded it, and it had seven bedrooms and about 6,300 square feet of interior space, USA Today reported. A trust bought it. Two months later the house was gone. In June 2026 the bare lot sold for $39.2 million, $6.2 million more than the house had brought a year earlier, according to The Real Deal.
Three months later and a few addresses down Island Drive, a land trust paid $40 million for 608 Island Drive. That house was finished in 2019 and has 5,900 square feet, five bedrooms and a 0.44-acre Intracoastal lot.
So on the same street in the same year, almost the same check bought two very different things. One was a recently built house on less than half an acre. The other was 0.84 acre with no house on it. Everglades Island's 2026 sales show how this enclave sets prices, and the sales comps a buyer receives will not explain it.
Four Sales on One Street
Everglades Island is a man-made strip off the main island of Palm Beach, and Island Drive is its only street, as the Palm Beach Daily News has described it. This year it produced four of the island's most closely watched trades.
| Address | Recorded 2026 | Price | What changed hands | Land | Price per acre, our arithmetic |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 757 Island Drive | May | about $93.3M | New house of about 11,637 sq ft under air, still under construction at sale | 0.9 acre, water on two sides | about $104M |
| 690 Island Drive | June | $39.2M | Vacant lot with dock | 0.84 acre, 175 ft of Intracoastal frontage | about $47M |
| 608 Island Drive | September | $40M | House completed 2019, 5,900 sq ft | 0.44 acre | about $91M |
| 593 Island Drive | October | $28.8M | House built 1999, 5,000 sq ft | 0.37 acre | about $78M |
Each lot has its own exposure and frontage, so the per-acre column is a rough guide and not a formal appraisal. It does show one pattern clearly. The land-only sale prices at about $47 million an acre. The three sales that included a house price at about $78 million to $104 million an acre. Measured per acre, a finished house on Everglades Island roughly doubles what the ground alone brings.
The 690 trade shows the other side of that. A remodeled 1949 house of about 6,300 interior square feet added nothing a later buyer would pay for, because the lot sold for more after the house was taken down. On this street a house adds value when it is recent and finished. When it is not, the market treats it as something to clear away.
Why Price Per Square Foot Breaks Here
Across the Town of Palm Beach, single-family homes that closed in Q3 2026 averaged $3,319 per square foot over 25 sales. The median sale price for the quarter was $10.556 million. The Everglades Island houses sold at roughly twice that rate. The 608 sale came to $6,765 per square foot, and 593 came to $5,850, according to The Real Deal's report on the October sale.
The 690 sale explains much of that rate. A vacant lot has no square footage, yet it sold for about the same money as the 2019 house. When a lot with no house prices level with a recent build, price per square foot is mostly measuring how small the house is relative to the land and water around it. Dividing by interior space spreads the cost of the frontage, the dock and the address over whatever house happens to stand there. A smaller house shows a higher figure for that reason alone.
This is why two Everglades Island houses with a $900-per-foot gap between them can both be fairly priced. The 1999 house at 593 sits on 0.37 acre and the 2019 house at 608 sits on 0.44 acre. The difference in land and the difference in the age of each house explain the gap better than any per-foot comparison does.
The Path From Lot to House, at 757
The 757 Island Drive record shows what the market pays for the step from land to a new house, and how long that step takes. The lot traded three times in ten years:
- Early 2016. The lot sold for $18.14 million.
- 2021. A buyer paid $39.5 million for the vacant corner parcel, which has about 371 feet of waterfront along its west and south sides, the Palm Beach Daily News reported.
- May 2022. The town's review panel approved a design with 11,637 square feet under air and 13,152 square feet including indoor and outdoor living space, according to the Palm Beach Daily News.
- May 2026. The house sold in an off-market deal for about $93.3 million while still under construction, as reported by The Palm Beach Post and The Real Deal.
The lot's 2021 price was within a few hundred thousand dollars of what 690's lot brought in 2026. Almost five years separate those two land prices. In that time, the house going up on the 2021 lot more than doubled the land value, and it found a buyer before construction was complete.
That is how to read the June 2026 buyer of 690 Island Drive. The buyer, an LLC managed by attorney Paul Krasker, paid about what 757's lot cost five years earlier for a parcel of similar size with Intracoastal frontage and a private dock. The other choice on the street was a finished house like 608: about the same money, half the land, and no design review or construction schedule to wait through.
What the Rest of the Island Is Adding to the Pressure
Everglades Island is the clearest example of a pressure building across Palm Beach. The Palm Beach Daily News reported on Oct. 21, 2026 that the island had 63 single-family houses actively listed in the MLS, compared with 75 a year earlier. Single-family sales in June, July and August more than doubled year over year. Agents in the same report said new, newer and newly renovated move-in-ready houses were the hardest to find.
"The inventory of better-quality houses, one seasoned broker said, is the tightest he has ever seen."
The top of the market moved as well. In a separate Oct. 21 report, the Palm Beach Daily News counted 13 sales at or near $29 million or more among deeds recorded from May 1 to Oct. 8, 2026, compared with nine in the same window of 2025. Everglades Island contributed several of those.
When finished, high-quality houses are this scarce, buyers will pay a lot for one, and a vacant waterfront lot becomes a way to get one by building it. Both effects show up on Island Drive. A 2019 house on under half an acre brought $40 million. A cleared lot, bought as an older house only a year earlier, sold at a $6.2 million gain. For a buyer comparing the two, the question is what is being paid for. A finished house is paid for in land, at roughly double the per-acre rate. A lot is paid for in time.
A Short FAQ
Do buyers at this level finance their purchases? Some do. The buyer of 593 Island Drive took a $19.5 million Bank of America loan to be repaid within 15 years. The mortgage carries a second-home rider, which means the house must be available to the owner for part of the year and not leased out, according to The Real Deal. This is general information and not legal, tax or financial advice. Loan terms and ownership structures should be confirmed with your own lender, attorney and tax advisor.
Did these sales reach the open market? Not all of them. The 757 and 593 trades were reported as off-market. The 608 house was listed in June at $41 million before it sold for $40 million. The Oct. 21 Daily News report also noted that the MLS gives no sign of houses being shopped privately by their owners.
How long had the older houses been held? The 593 house last sold in 1997, for $1.9 million. Its October sale was the property's first in nearly 30 years. Barrett's family had owned the 690 house since the mid-1970s, and she paid $6.1 million for it in 2005.
If you are deciding whether to pay for a finished house on Everglades Island or for the land and time to build one, Margit Brandt Palm Beach can review the Island Drive record against your plans and timeline. Request a private consultation.